So, You’re Done with Your Pool… Now What?
Maybe your pool has turned into more of a money pit than a backyard oasis. Maybe the kids have grown up, and instead of splashy summers, you’re left with leaves, maintenance bills, and a vague sense of regret. Whatever the reason, you’ve decided it’s time to reclaim your backyard.
Now comes the big question: Do you remove the pool entirely, or do you just fill it in?
A lot of people assume that getting rid of a pool means tearing it out completely, but that’s not the only option. A pool fill-in can save you time and money while still giving you back your yard. Let’s break down the differences so you can make the best decision for your home.
What is Pool Removal? (AKA: The Clean-Slate Option)
Pool removal is exactly what it sounds like—your pool is completely excavated, dismantled, and taken away, leaving you with an empty space that can be used however you want. This is the most thorough way to eliminate a pool, but it comes with a bigger price tag and a longer process.
Two Types of Pool Removal:
- Partial Pool Removal/Pool Fill-In
- The upper section of the pool is broken up, but the lower part stays in place.
- The remaining structure is filled with compacted dirt and gravel.
- It’s faster and less expensive than full removal but may come with some resale restrictions.
- Full Pool Removal
- Every piece of the pool is completely removed.
- You can build anything in its place—a garden, a patio, or even an addition to your home.
- Costs more but eliminates any potential issues with property disclosures.
What is Pool Fill-In? (AKA: The Budget-Friendly Method)
Pool fill-in is the less invasive option—it’s faster, more affordable, and still gives you a functional backyard. Instead of digging up and hauling everything away, the pool is simply filled in with a mix of dirt, gravel, and sand. Once compacted properly, the space can be used for gardens, lawns, patios, or even a fire pit area.
Pros of Pool Fill-In:
✅ Less expensive than full removal
✅ Faster process—often completed in a few days
✅ No more pool maintenance headaches
✅ Great for landscaping projects
Cons of Pool Fill-In:
❌ The old pool structure is still buried
❌ May need disclosure when selling your home
❌ Heavy structures (like a garage or home addition) may not be ideal for this space
Key Differences at a Glance
| Feature | Pool Removal | Pool Fill-In |
| Cost | $$$$ (More expensive) | $$ (More affordable) |
| Time | Takes longer (possibly weeks) | Quicker (days) |
| Resale Impact | No restrictions | May require disclosure |
| Future Land Use | Any structure (patio, home addition, garage) | Best for landscaping & light structures |
How to Choose the Right Option for Your Property
Ask yourself these questions before deciding:
- What’s your budget? Pool fill-in is definitely the budget-friendly option.
- Do you plan to build something on top later? If yes, you may want to consider full removal.
- Are you selling your home soon? Some areas require pool fill-ins to be disclosed, which could impact buyers.
- How quickly do you want this done? Fill-ins can often be completed in just a few days.
Reclaiming Your Backyard, Your Way
No matter which route you take, one thing’s for sure: life without pool maintenance is going to feel amazing. Whether you opt for a full removal or a simple fill-in, both options let you turn that unused pool into something functional, beautiful, and maintenance-free.
Contact The Pool Fill-In People to discuss your options if you’re still on the fence. After all, your backyard should be a place of relaxation, not a source of stress.